Creamery Goodies

A unique recipe of blended extra virgin olive oil, fresh fried garlic, shallots, and chili peppers makes for the perfect combination of heat and flavor. We pour this on everything, especially our Fresh Chevre!

You won't use another caramel again! THE FLAVOR EXPERIENCE Fat Toad Farm's handmade, small batch caramel, with sea salt and Kentucky Straight Bourbon. This caramel is made with fresh goat's milk, cane sugar, pure sea salt, and finished with Kentucky...

You won't use another caramel again! THE FLAVOR EXPERIENCE Organic French Bourbon vanilla beans are generously sprinkled throughout this sweet and velvety caramel sauce. THE STORY Located in central Vermont, Fat Toad Farm uses a herd of 60 Alpine...

100% Goat Meat. Humanely and Naturally Raised on our Farm. Delicious!  6 oz.

Artisan made crackers to pair with your delicious Door County Creamery cheeses. 

  Due to the frozen nature of Gelato all other items combined with a Gelato order will arrive frozen (which is ok). If you prefer to have your other items not frozen you will need to make another order to ship separately. ENJOY...we know you...

Our cookies have had a cult following since the day we started baking...try some and see why! Every batch starts with all-butter, pure-cane-sugar and cage-free-egg cookie dough and promises ingredients that are GMO free, additive free and sustainable.

All Sauces are made in small batches from a time old recipe passed down from the best Jerk Chicken chef in our family. You're part of the local movement, so you understand how important it is to keep our city vibrant and moving forward. We're...

All Sauces are made in small batches from a time old recipe passed down from the best Jerk Chicken chef in our family. You're part of the local movement, so you understand how important it is to keep our city vibrant and moving forward. We're...